First published 2026.11.09
Community Libraries
There have been several major upsets in the past few months, building on changes we’ve been seeing over the past few years, around how popular web platforms handle art and other content outside the boundaries of the “safe for work”.
On one hand, these platforms are making sensible policy decisions around User Generated Content; running afoul of payment processors like Mastercard and Visa or vague new legislation in the UK can close the platform, destroying its business and broader community. From this perspective, it makes sense to refuse the margin and focus on the mainstream, which is what we’ve seen Patreon and Tumblr do to ensure they continue existing.
On the other hand, this works to further marginalize communities, workers, and artists who exist outside the mainstream. Platform policy becomes a gate not only on community health, but broader culture and what gets to be seen as “acceptable”.
Examples of policy decisions that exclude communities from the mainstream include Itch.io deciding the remove huge numbers of indie games with queer themes from their index, Tumblr banning pornographic and adult works, and Cloudflare shutting down Glitch rather than engage with solving spam concerns.
The internet adapts, however, and exclusion from a platform drives the creation of new platforms - Archive Of Our Own and OnlyFans step in the provide a space for these communities where Tumblr and Patreon refuse to. Specialist fetish platforms create space for specialist sex workers.
New platforms don’t solve the underlying problem, they move the lines further into the margin but remain subject to the same forces of exclusion. New legislation can force their hand, or technical problems take it down for months. The platform remains a central arbiter for who gets to participate in a community.
What if communities could take this role back from the platforms?
Community Over Platform
What if, instead of posting work to a platform, you posted work to your own website.
The benefit is that nothing can take it down off the web that’s outside your control. The detriment is that your work doesn’t sit next to the rest of the community, doesn’t become findable, isn’t a part of a broader corpus of work where the community gathers. It’s atomized and personal - the original dream of the internet.
Can we keep the benefit, but solve the detriment? Does the platform need to play both roles - community gathering space and hosting provider?
We think you can.
An Octothorpes server is a self contained, community run index that acts as that community gathering space. It invites anyone with a website to participate, encouraging them to tag their web pages however that please to build a “search engine in reverse” for their work.
Anyone can start an Octothorpes server, and each one gets to define the rules it wants for its community. What is allowed? What is not allowed? What does this community want to create and value?
And because the community is separated from the work, a page can participate in as many communities as they want. Exclusion from a community means “not right for here” rather than “we deleted your work”. If an Octothorpes server goes down, the work is safe. Add it to a new one and the community can rebuild itself anywhere.
An Index of Our Own
A community library that collects writing under a rich array of tags only needs a team to manage the community.
A game shelf dedicated to indie games, reviews, and tips only needs a curator.
A loose collection of experimental web developers can push the boundaries of the web, building off each others work.
An arts movement, a sub-genre, a fetish. Your community can organize itself, have a place to gather, and build something together.
Let’s Get Started Today
If any of these sound like something you want to be a part of, or has given you your own brilliant idea, reach out to nk@stucco.software and we’ll make it happen.